iDEA Inspiring Digital Enterprise Awards

Choice anxiety

The original notion of Choice Anxiety was first written about in 1844 by Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard in a work that translates into English as 'The Concept of Anxiety'.

Kierkegaard argued that choice induced anxiety. He cited the first anxiety experienced by man, as the choice Adam faced in whether or not to eat the fruit of the tree of knowledge. Before Adam knew that eating fruit from this tree was forbidden, there was no decision to be made - everything was allowed.

On average, a person has made 0 decisions in the time since you loaded this page

This extends to the notion of ‘Decision Fatigue’ which refers to the deteriorating quality of decisions made by an individual after a long session of decision making.

From the moment you wake up, your brain consciously or subconsciously starts making decisions. This can be anything from whether to stay in bed for another five minutes or get up, to whether to have a pudding or not or whether to do some exercise or finish this badge. It has been claimed that the average person makes 35,000 decisions a day. That’s roughly a decision every two and a half seconds.

Interestingly, major politicians and businessmen such as former US President Barack Obama, Steve Jobs and Mark Zuckerberg have been known to reduce their everyday clothing down to one or two outfits in order to limit the number of decisions they make in a day.

The same applies to your web page.

Giving a visitor too many options, can lead to choice anxiety. Allied to decision fatigue this can lead to ‘Decision avoidance’, a phenomenon identified by Christopher Anderson in his 2003 psychological bulletin ‘The Psychology of Doing Nothing: Forms of Decision Avoidance Result from Reason and Emotion’.

Put simply, give people too much choice, and too many decisions will lead them to avoiding all of them and doing nothing. In the case of your web page this means they will leave it rather than continue.

Goals in Web Design

To make sure the user experience of your site is as smooth as possible, and that choice anxiety is kept to a minimum, every web page on your site should have a purpose and it is your job to make that purpose as clear to the visitor as possible.

What do you think the primary purpose for each of the following pages is?

What is the primary purpose of

A news page?

Correct

Correct!

A news story is there to be read.

Incorrect

Hmmm. Are you sure?

What is the primary purpose of

A product page on an e-commerce website?

Correct

Correct!

A product page should entice the user to want to buy the product.

Incorrect

Hmmm. Are you sure?

What is the primary purpose of

The homepage of a website?

Correct

Correct!

A website homepage should make it easy for the visitor to find the information they want.

Incorrect

Hmmm. Are you sure?

What is the primary purpose of

An about page on a company website?

Correct

Correct!

People visit an About page to find out more about a company.

Incorrect

Hmmm. Are you sure?

White space

Press the Add to Basket button on this product page:

Good. Now press the Add to Basket button on this product page:

Excellent. Which one was clearer and easier to find?

Correct

Correct!

Incorrect

Hmmm. Are you sure?

The use of white space helped direct your eye to the most important part of the page (although it is called white space, it really refers just to the space around items - it doesn’t matter what colour the background is).

Cramming too much information in to a page can lead to the goals of your web page being overwhelmed or masked. Visitors won’t know where to start, and the danger is that they may do nothing and just leave the site.

Items can also be grouped together through the use of white space, by decreasing the space between them and increasing the space between them and other items on the page. This is important for showing the relationships between items. For example it was clear that the Buy Now button was associated with the product in the example above because it was grouped with it and the group was separated from the other content.

Correct

Well done!

So, your user has formed their first impression of the site; you’ve successfully reassured them that your site is safe and that they are in the right place.

Now you need to do everything you can to achieve the goals of your website or page, which hopefully mirror the needs of the visitor.

Next Step